What Does Sending a Kid to Their Room, a Behavior Plan, and a Sugar Cookie Have in Common?
It is cookie season, and every sugar cookie starts out exactly the same, same dough, same cutter, same shape. What happens after that is where the real work begins, the icing, the piping, the sprinkles, each one different depending on the cookie in front of you.
Early in my career, I worked in residential care with teens who had been through more than most adults ever will. One of them asked me something I still think about today. She wanted to know why I was not sending her to her room when she acted out, since that was the consequence she saw other kids get on TV. The program I worked for at the time followed a philosophy that said to ignore negative behavior entirely and redirect to the positive. On paper, it made sense. For her, it did not work at all.
Eventually, with a behaviorist’s help, we built something different for her, a plan that did include a consequence she recognized. It worked. But understanding why it worked took me years, long after I had left that job.
Why Training Matters
There is a message going around right now suggesting that executive function coaching is simple, that staying just a little ahead of the student you are working with is enough, and that extensive training is a waste of time.
Part of that is fair. Plenty of people stall out collecting course after course, telling themselves they will start coaching once they know everything. If that describes you, the truth is you do not need to know everything to begin.
But knowing enough to begin is different from knowing enough to recognize when a base strategy is not working, and why. Tracking a goal and building accountability are the easy part. The hard part, the part that actually changes outcomes, is understanding what is happening underneath the behavior you are seeing. That is not something a simple system teaches you to notice. It is something training teaches you to notice.
My case above is proof of that. The behavior plan everyone had agreed on was simple and well intentioned. It just was not built with her brain in mind. It took understanding, not just a system, to figure out what actually would work.
Here is what I understand now that I did not have language for then.
The brain’s motivational circuit, driven largely through the prefrontal cortex, does not switch on just because a behavior plan says it should. It switches on when something carries meaning. Not meaning in the abstract sense, meaning to that specific person, built from their specific history and what they are actually trying to get out of a moment.
For her, being sent to her room was not a punishment. It was proof that she was being treated like every other kid. In a life that had been anything but typical, that mattered enormously. The redirect to positive approach never touched that. It addressed the behavior on the surface without ever asking what the behavior meant to her.
This is where motivation and executive function stop being separate conversations. The reward circuit, which drives whether a behavior feels worth repeating, and the motivational circuit, which drives whether a student engages with a task at all, are not sitting off to the side from skills like task initiation, emotional regulation, or self monitoring. They are feeding directly into them. A student who cannot find meaning in a task is not simply unmotivated. Their brain has little reason to activate the very systems that would help them start, regulate, and follow through. Task initiation fails not because the skill is missing, but because the circuit that would drive someone to use that skill was never engaged in the first place.
That is the interplay that gets missed when coaching starts and ends with a single base strategy. You cannot build working memory supports, or organization systems, or self monitoring routines, on top of a motivational circuit that has nothing to hold onto. The strategy has to connect to something the student’s brain actually registers as worth doing.
For her, the worthy thing was a sense of belonging. Once the plan reflected that, everything else we tried had somewhere to land.
Understand the Brain Before You Intervene
Inside the Decode Bootcamp and the Coaching Clarity Kit, we teach this through a framework we call BRAIN. It is not a diagnostic tool. It is a structured way to organize what you actually know about a student’s brain, what you do not know yet, and what you need to find out before building a plan around them.
Begin with the brain, what do we already know about this student’s neurological and developmental history. Review the relevant architecture, what do testing and EF measures actually tell us about how this brain functions. Ask what could be influencing it day to day; sleep, stress, sensory factors, the demands of their environment. Identify what is clear and what is still unclear, including the assumptions we might be making without realizing it. Name the next steps, what do we still need to learn, and what tells us whether the plan needs to change.
Why This Matters
A base system is not a bad place to start. But it was never meant to be the finished product. That is the whole difference between a cookie cutter and a decorated cookie. The base plan is never enough on its own. The real work is in the decorating, and that only happens once you understand the brain in front of you well enough to know what that particular student needs, and why.