What Changed My Thinking About Motivation

When I first began coaching, I spent a lot of time searching for motivation activities.

I remember trying to help students shift from a "negative mindset" into a "positive mindset," believing that if we could just help them think differently, they would become more motivated. And while mindset absolutely matters, it wasn't until I began studying executive function and brain architecture more deeply that my understanding of motivation started changing.

Recently, I was working with an adult client who was struggling to motivate himself to get to work in the morning. What fascinated me was how similar some of the patterns felt to what I often see with students. Different environment, same underlying struggle.

At first, we explored many of the practical supports people naturally think about: bedtime routines, wake-up routines, environmental structure, and morning habits. But despite all of that, something still felt stuck.

The real shift happened when we stopped focusing only on the routine itself and started talking about meaning. We explored what his workday represented for his future, his goals, his stability, and the kind of life he wanted to build.

That was the moment things started changing.

One of the biggest shifts in my coaching came when I stopped viewing motivation as simply a matter of mindset or willpower and started understanding it as a brain-based process. And that shift started with a client.

The deeper I studied executive function and brain architecture, the more I realized that in order for an individual to become motivated, the prefrontal cortex has to perceive something as meaningful enough to engage with.

That understanding completely changed the questions I ask during coaching. Instead of focusing only on how to get someone to "do the task," I became much more curious about what meaning the individual attached to the task in the first place, and whether the brain actually perceived the effort as worth the emotional and cognitive energy required to begin.

Why meaning impacts activation

The longer I worked with students and adults, the more I realized that motivation is not simply about whether someone wants to succeed. Many of the individuals I worked with cared deeply. They wanted good grades. They wanted stability. They wanted success. And yet they still struggled to consistently activate.

That disconnect fascinated me for years.

Over time, I began realizing that meaning plays a much larger role in activation than most people recognize. The brain is constantly evaluating whether something feels emotionally relevant enough to justify the effort, attention, and energy required to begin. When individuals connect personally to why something matters, activation often becomes easier because the brain begins perceiving the task differently.

That was exactly what happened with the client I mentioned earlier. The routines themselves were not wrong, but routines alone were not enough to create consistent activation. The shift happened when he emotionally reconnected to what work represented in his life and began reminding himself of that meaning intentionally each morning.

How motivation and executive function overlap

One of the reasons motivation can feel so complicated is because it overlaps with so many executive function processes at the same time.

Task initiation, working memory, emotional regulation, future awareness, planning, and self-monitoring all influence whether someone is able to begin and sustain action. That means what looks like "lack of motivation" is often much more layered underneath the surface.

Sometimes individuals struggle because the task feels cognitively overwhelming. Sometimes the brain predicts failure before the task even begins. Sometimes the future reward feels too distant to create enough activation in the present moment. And sometimes the individual simply cannot emotionally connect to why the task matters strongly enough for the brain to sustain effort.

This is one of the reasons executive function coaching often requires us to look beyond visible behavior and become more curious about what is happening underneath it.

Why routines alone sometimes fail

I still believe routines matter deeply. Structure reduces cognitive load, habits can support consistency, and predictable systems can make activation easier. But one of the biggest things I have learned over time is that routines alone do not always solve the problem.

I think this is where many students and adults become frustrated with themselves. They create the planner, set the alarms, establish the schedule, and still find themselves unable to consistently follow through. And when that happens, people often assume the issue is laziness, lack of discipline, or lack of effort.

But sometimes the missing piece is meaning.

A routine can provide structure, but if the brain does not perceive enough emotional relevance or personal value connected to the task itself, activation can still feel incredibly difficult. The brain has to perceive not only what needs to happen, but why it matters enough to begin.

How coaches can help students reconnect to meaningful action

One of the biggest changes in my coaching over the years has been shifting from simply trying to increase compliance to helping students reconnect to meaningful action.

Sometimes that means exploring future goals and helping students visualize what they are building toward. Sometimes it means helping them connect a task to independence, relief, confidence, stability, or opportunity. Sometimes it means helping students identify values that matter to them personally rather than relying entirely on external pressure.

And sometimes it means acknowledging that a task genuinely does not feel meaningful and helping students build enough emotional connection to tolerate the discomfort anyway.

Because motivation is not simply about forcing action through pressure or positivity.

Often, it is about helping the brain perceive enough meaning for activation to begin.

Interested in understanding more about executive function? Become a Certified Executive Function Strategist! Join us for our next Mastering Executive Function course! There are two days and times to choose from - we begin in August! Click below to register.